A stainable wood filling formula can be used to repair unsightly cracks, holes, and other signs of damaged wood, but not all can withstand the test of time.
There are many stainable wood fillers on the market that blend well in the beginning, only to resist stain and shrink once dry. To avoid this, I’m here to share the best stainable wood fillers for interior and exterior applications!
Reviews of the Top Stainable Wood Fillers
1. FamoWood 40022126 Latex Wood Filler
The FamoWood 40022126 filler is among the best stainable wood filler in the market, and a better alternative for epoxy wood fillers. In fact, it is one of the most versatile and stainable formulas being sold. This latex wood filler comes in various types of colors and tones that you don’t need to sand, stain or paint.
Aside from that, this latex filler does not have any strong smell and odor as it is solvent-free. It is also ideal for massive repair, project, and wood furniture.
It’s fast-drying, and within 15 minutes you can prepare the formula nice and firm. You won’t have to worry whether it would shrink or crack.
What I Like
- You won't need to paint or stain simultaneously as you can choose from different colors and available tones
- It sets fast but does not shrink and crack in the long run
- It can be used to fill and repair enormous gouges and holes of both furniture and surface
- It works well for outdoor use
- It is very affordable
What I Don’t Like
- Its availability can vary
- Its shelf life can be longer
2. J-B Weld 40007 Wood Restore Epoxy Putty Kit
The J-B Weld 40007 Epoxy kit is a heavy-duty epoxy wood filler. This kit comprises a two-component system – resin and hardener – which are mixed together using a putty knife. An important thing to bear in mind with this product is its rapid drying time, setting it apart from most wood fillers.
When using this epoxy, it’s crucial to work efficiently. You should apply the mixture to your wood project or repair areas within a window of 10 minutes before it begins to cure. Approximately, an hour is all it takes for the epoxy to set.
For optimal results, I’d recommend leaving it undisturbed for an entire day. Right after, you can mold and sand it down the way you like, similar to natural wood.
What I Like
- Its heavy-duty and strong formulation makes it ideal for demanding repair tasks
- It does not shrink
- This epoxy provides structural strength to rotted wood
- It contains no solvents
- Its ease of use makes it accessible for those less experienced in wood repairs
- You can sand and tap finished surfaces in 60 minutes
What I Don’t Like
- It dries up fast; it can’t be manipulated once cured
- This wood filler is a bit expensive that the others on this list
3. Elmer’s E887Q Stainable Wood Filler, 3.25-Ounce
The Elmer’s E887Q is very easy to use, thanks in part to its packaging in a plastic container which allowed me to access the filler easily. It is a creamy formula that lets you mix everything without a hassle.
You can just squeeze out the product and fill any holes like a stripped wood screw hole, or cracks and damages on wood. Another good thing about Elmer’s E887Q Stainable Wood Filler is it creates a less bumpy wood when it dries out. You won’t notice the filler that has been applied.
This wood filler epoxy formula works well for both indoor and outdoor projects,bolstered by its water-resistant properties. For more options, check the top-quality epoxy wood fillers here!
What I Like
- This filler does not shrink over time, maintaining the integrity of the repair
- It's perfect for staining, blending seamlessly with the wood.
- It dries up within 15 minutes or less
- Being solvent-free makes it safer and more environmentally friendly
- It is applicable for both indoor and outdoor use
- It flattens when applied to any cracks or holes
- It's ideal for personal or DIY projects due to its ease of use
- The creamy consistency of the filler makes it easy to handle and apply
What I Don’t Like
- It comes in a small tube which means it has less amount of product
- You need to seal it tightly to avoid drying
4. Minwax 42853000 Stainable Wood Filler, 16 ounce
The Minwax 42853000 Stainable Wood Filler works flawlessly, be it on oil-based or water-based surfaces. The wood filler (16 ounce) can be used on virtually every material, and not just on wood.
You can rely on it for both exterior or interior applications. There’s no long waiting time as well since it dries up fast within at least 15 minutes. However, it’s important to note that due to its fast-drying nature, this stainable wood filler is primarily recommended for small projects.
However, it’s important to note that due to its fast-drying nature, this stainable wood filler is primarily recommended for small projects. The rapid curing of the filler means that it might not be the best choice for larger projects where more time is needed to manipulate and shape the formula effectively.
What I Like
- This Minwax filler is very easy to sand
- It is a good wood filler for repairing both outdoor and indoor furniture or any wood surfaces
- It dries within 15 minutes or less
- It will not shrink or crack
- The consistency makes it easy to work with
What I Don’t Like
- It is not recommended for repairing a big project or furniture
- It can clump on application
5. Bondo All-Purpose Putty
Another best stainable wood filler in the market is 3M Bondo All-Purpose Putty, which is a polyester putty product. When it comes to repairing, this type of formula promises a same-day result as you can complete the whole process within 30 minutes.
Just mix the filler and hardener and sand the filler for about 15 minutes. Afterward, the formula will be ready for sanding and staining, unlike any other wood filler products that take up to 24 hours to be cured.
However, since it sets very fast, you must be accurate because you can’t manipulate the formula. I’d recommend planning ahead your project before using this type of wood filler.
What I Like
- This wood filler is ideal for heavy-duty repairs, projects, or large furniture
- It can be used to fill real wood issues such as cracks, holes, gouges, and more
- It won’t shrink in the long run
- Its formula is extremely durable and strong, indicative of a high-quality epoxy
- It can be used to fill other types of material
What I Don’t Like
- It won’t allow you a lot of working time as it dries up very fast
- The color change when mixing is not distinct
6. Goodfilla Water-Based Wood & Grain Filler
The Goodfilla Water-Based Stainable Wood Filler is an affordable choice that does not shrink or crack. You only need to apply it once on surfaces, and then it does the job with any wood stains or finishes.
The application process is straightforward, and it seamlessly integrates with any wood stains or finishes, making it a versatile choice for various projects. This stainable filling can also be kept for a long time.
Besides being able to reconstitute with water, it doesn’t freeze during colder seasons. The Goodfilla stainable wood filler is also a time saver because it is easy to sand. Additionally, its non-toxic nature and zero-waste formulation make it an environmentally friendly and safe choice for use in various woodworking applications.
What I Like
- The formula has excellent adhesion
- It guarantees unlimited shelf life because it reconstitutes with water
- It is easy to sand
- It is non-toxic and has zero waste
- You can refund it up to a year
- It is made in the USA
What I Don’t Like
- It is not as absorbent as desired
- The smell can be overpowering
7. Timbermate Wood Filler
The Timbermate wood filler is easy to use and versatile that’s suitable for a variety of materials like maple, pine, or beech, and many other wood types.
This filler sets itself apart by working quickly without shrinking, cracking, or falling out, while still providing enough time to apply finish and make adjustments before it sets permanently.
This product promises zero waste [1]. Just scoop up the filling that’s left unused back into the container. If you’re not happy with your application, removal is easy as watering it down. The Timbermate Wood Filler does freeze when put aside, but you can thaw it by putting it in the microwave.
What I Like
- The formula is easy to use and prepare
- The best stainable wood filler for ease of use
- It can be used for all sorts of repairs
- The drying time is quick
- It's a zero waste product
What I Don’t Like
- The wood filler can freeze overtime when left on the shelf
- It can react with tools that are not plastic or stainless steel
Stainable Wood Filler Buyers Guide
Want to know how I rounded up this list of the best wood fillers? Here are some factors to to keep in mind when choosing the reliable product.
Purpose/Use
To effectively address larger holes or cracks in your project, I recommend opting for a wood filler available in bulk packaging. Opting for products in small amounts or containers may not provide sufficient coverage for extensive repairs. Purchasing in larger quantities will save you time and money.
If you intend to only use it for a one-time repair or to fill a small hole, then products with smaller amounts are ideal. For heavy-duty projects and emergency purposes, it’s better to purchase the massive ones.
Type of Stainable Wood Filler
There are two types of wood fillers: water-based and solvent-based wood fillers.
Water-based wood fillers use water as their primary base. This type of stainable wood filler is composed of wood fibers, gypsum, and cellulose. This type has a long shelf life, is non-toxic, and is very safe to use. It does not produce a strong odor which makes it ideal for indoor use.
On the other hand, solvent-based wood fillers can be easily noticed by their strong and overpowering smell. But compared to water-based filler, this type of filler has stronger resistance when it comes to humidity and temperature. For this reason, I recommend this filler for your pieces outdoors.
Overall, the type of filler should depends on where you intend to use it. Assess your project and pick a suitable filler type.
Versatility
One characteristic of the best wood filler is its capability to adapt a stain and paint. A wood filler should have a good staining or painting rate. This determines the right formula because it should have a smooth finish after stain or paint.
Another factor to consider when selecting a product is the drying time of the wood stain. People often think that fast-drying solutions are always better since they won’t accumulate longer waiting times. However, there are other things to factor in.
When working on a massive project, you should opt for the slow-to-dry fillers so you can still have the opportunity to manipulate the formula once applied. Only use the fast drying filler when you intend to use it for small projects and repairs.
Aside from the stainable ones, you can also opt for drillable fillers in wood for added versatility.
Wood Putty or Wood Filler?
I cannot stress this enough, but there’s a big difference between a wood putty and a wood filler. A wood putty is an oil-based formula, often used in furnished wood, and can be used in any type of surroundings and conditions.
Wood fillers can be water-based and solvent-based which is ideally used indoors and sometimes outdoors.
If you intend to use a product to fill in big holes, smoothen unfinished lumber, flatten out a porous surface, and repairs that need a quick turnaround, then wood filler is the best choice.
But if you are thinking of using it on a varnished surface or furniture, wood putty is an efficient alternative. Just by using a putty knife or even your finger, you can easily dab the formula to fill or cover the intended area. It has a lot of available shades as well that can easily match the stain of the surfaces.
How To Use Stainable Wood Filler
Step #1: To apply wood filler, squeeze out enough product, spread it to the intended area, and gently press it using a putty knife.
Step #2: Fill up until above the surface to allow sanding. Remove excess when done.
Step #3: Allow the fillers to dry up completely. Leave it for a few hours.
Step #4: Smoothen out the surface by sanding and clear any residue once finished.
Step #5: Before the filler dries up, clean and rinse your hand by using soap and water.
After it dries up, you will have to stain the filler. Pick a stain that matches the color and tone to achieve a brand new-looking platform. To avoid mistakes, test out the stain on scrap wood.
Once you get the perfect shade of stain, apply a protective clear finish for a long-lasting result.
Other Shop Essentials:
FAQ
Does a stainable wood filler work?
Yes, wood fillers are widely used as a primary formula for repairing imperfections. Some wood fillers are appropriate for large holes and gaps, while others are only appropriate for small holes and gaps. It dries up fast and does its job perfectly without compromising the quality.
Are wood fillers as strong as wood?
Wood fillers, while versatile and useful for repairing cracks, holes, and imperfections in wood, are generally not as strong as solid wood.
They are designed to be easy to apply and sand, and can often be stained to match the surrounding wood, but their primary purpose is cosmetic repair rather than structural support.
How are wood fillers prepared?
Most often, these fillers come in a kit. You will only need to mix the wood particles with the binder until it is blended evenly.
My Top Pick For a Stainable Wood Filler: FamoWood 40022126 Latex Filler
Among the numerous products I’ve used over the years, the best stainable wood filler for me is the FamoWood 40022126 Latex Filler.
This filler is very versatile as it comes in different shades and tones. It also lasts long and is very durable. In addition, it does not emit any strong odor as it is water-based. This wood filler’s drying time might be fast it works well for both outdoor and indoor use.
Robert Johnson is a passionate furniture maker & carpenter, sought after for his knowledge on the craft.
You’ve probably seen his down-to-earth wisdom in USA Today, Bobvila, Family Handyman, and The Spruce, where he has shared commentary and guidance on various woodworking topics.
Robert is the brain behind Sawinery, where he aims to share tips, tricks, and a passion for all things carpentry.
