Filling nail holes looks simple, but a bad putty job shows up in every angle of light once the paint or finish goes on. The right putty should level cleanly, dry at a predictable rate, and sand down without creating dips or glossy patches.Â
We keep a few different putties on hand because trim, stained wood, and painted furniture all behave differently when nail holes are filled. We tested several options across pine trim, oak cabinets, MDF, and furniture stock.Â
The products below stood out for bonding well, remaining easy to work with, and finishing clean after sanding or staining. Each offers a slightly different advantage, so choose based on whether your project is painted, stained, or built from hardwood or softwood.
Best Putty for Nail Holes in 2025
1. DAP Plastic Wood All Purpose Wood Filler
A solvent-based filler with strong adhesion for trim and furniture
This is one of the strongest all-purpose fillers we have used in the shop. We found it bonds tightly in nail holes, especially in pine and hardwood trim. Once it dries, it sands down to a very smooth surface that blends well under primer and paint. For us, it was especially reliable on door casings where movement tends to crack lighter fillers.
We also noticed that it sets faster than water-based putties, which made it helpful during production work. The consistency stays firm, so it is easy to press into deeper nail holes without sagging.
Pros:Â
- Strong bond
- Smooth sanding
- Minimal shrinkage
Cons:Â
- Noticeable odor
- Dries quickly if left open
Specs:Â
- Solvent-based
- Interior and exterior
- Available in multiple wood tones
Â
2. 3M Bondo Home Solutions Wood Filler
A two-part filler known for fast curing and high strength
Bondo is one of the toughest fillers we tested. In our shop, we use it when nail holes need a permanent fix that will not shrink or crack, especially on painted surfaces. We found the two-part system cures quickly and sands to a hard, paint-ready finish. It is also helpful when you need to shape or feather repairs on thicker trim.
For us, the downside is the time required to work. You need to mix small batches because it begins to cure fast. Once you adjust to the pace, it becomes a dependable choice for high-durability work.
Pros:Â
- Extremely strong
- Fast curing
- No shrink
Cons:Â
- Short working time
Specs:Â
- Two-part fillerÂ
- Interior and exterior
- Sandable in 15 minutes
Â
3. Minwax Stainable Wood Filler
A wood filler formulated to accept stains more evenly
This product helped us match nail holes on oak, pine, and birch where a painted filler would stand out. We found it absorbed stain more predictably than most fillers labeled stainable. While it does not completely eliminate stains, it blends well when combined with a light touch-up with stain markers.
In our workshop, it's sanded cleanly, although it dries quickly, so you must work it into nail holes right away. For stained furniture and natural wood finishes, it remained one of the closest matches.
Pros:Â
- Accepts stain reasonably well
- Easy to sand
- Good color options
Cons:Â
- Can darken slightly more than the surrounding wood
Specs:Â
- Water-based
- Interior use
- Tinted wood tones
4. Elmer’s Carpenter’s Wood Filler
A reliable water-based filler suited for trim and interior projects
We use this filler for day-to-day trim work because it spreads easily and sands down without clogging the sandpaper. For us, it worked exceptionally well on MDF and poplar, where even light sanding can create dips. The filler stays workable long enough to shape, yet dries fast enough for same-day finishing.
We also noticed it stays stable under latex paint and does not flash through the finish. It is not the hardest filler in this roundup, but it performs smoothly for basic nail hole work.
Pros:Â
- Easy to use
- Low odor
- Smooth sanding
Cons:Â
- Not as strong as solvent-based fillers
Specs:Â
- Water-based
- Interior use
- Available in white, natural, and oak
5. Howard Feed N Wax Fill Sticks
Wax-based fill sticks are used for quick repairs on stained and finished surfaces
These sticks are great for furniture or trim where sanding is not possible. We used them to fill nail holes on stained crown molding or stained doors. We found the wax blends very naturally with grain patterns and do not leave noticeable blotches. The application is simple: just rub the stick across the hole and buff.
For us, they are not ideal for raw wood or painted projects. They excel in situations where sanding would damage the finish.
Pros:Â
- No sanding required
- Blends well in stained wood
Cons:Â
- Not for paint
- Softer than other fillers
Specs:Â
- Wax-based
- Interior use
-
Multiple color sticks
6. Timbermate Water-Based Wood Filler
A high-quality, no-shrink filler that sands exceptionally well
Timbermate has one of the smoothest sanding profiles we have used. In our shop, it leveled cleanly even in end grain and did not shrink after drying. We noticed the filler stayed workable for a long time, which helped with larger batches of trim. It also rehydrates with water, so waste is minimal.
The consistency is thick, so you may thin it slightly for larger patches. For nail holes, it packs tightly and blends well under stain or paint, depending on the color.
Pros:Â
- No shrink
- Rehydratable
- Excellent sanding
Cons:Â
- Slight learning curve with consistency
Specs:Â
- Water based
- Interior use
- Comes in multiple wood tones
7. FamoWood Latex Wood Filler
A durable, fast-drying filler that handles both small and medium repairs.
We found FamoWood ideal for nail holes on hardwood trim because it bonds firmly without feeling brittle. It dries quickly, but not so fast that you lose working time. For us, the sanding experience was clean and predictable, even after using it in deeper countersunk nail holes.
On oak and maple, it accepted stains better than average latex fillers. Under paint, it disappeared completely once primed.
Pros:Â
- Strong bond
- Fast drying
- Works for hardwoods
Cons:Â
- Slightly thicker to spread
Specs:Â
- Latex-based
- Interior and exterior
- Multiple colors
8. Crawford’s Painter’s Putty
An old-school oil-based putty ideal for painted finish work
We keep this putty in the shop for painted trim because it smooths beautifully and holds shape even on moving materials like pine. We found it especially useful for nail holes along baseboards and door casings. The oil base gives a clean feather edge that does not flash through latex paint once primed.
For us, the slow drying time is the trade-off. If you have overnight dry time available, it is one of the best finishing putties for painted surfaces.
Pros:Â
- Very smooth
- No flashing
- Great for painters
Cons:Â
- Slow drying
Specs:Â
- Oil-based
- Interior use
- White finish
Choosing the Best Putty for Nail Holes
- Painted or Stained? Painted projects do best with latex or solvent-based fillers. Stained projects need stainable or wax-based options.
- Dry Time: Fast-drying fillers increase workflow speed but offer less working time.
- Shrink and Crack Resistance: Hardwoods, softwoods, and MDF move differently. Choose a filler that stays stable.
- Sandability: A good filler should sand flat without creating dips.
-
Safety: For proper surface preparation around dust-producing tasks, refer to OSHA’s wood dust safety guidelines.
Final Thoughts
The right putty makes nail holes disappear instead of highlighting every fastener in the trim. Some products offer strength, others blend better with stains, and a few stand out for fast workflow or no shrinkage performance.Â
The putties in this roundup earned their place because they stayed consistent across real projects and left clean surfaces after sanding or buffing. Once you match the putty to the finish and the type of wood you are working with, the results become cleaner, and the finishing stage goes much smoothly.
You may also like to read about:
Â
