As anyone who’s ever done any DIY around the house knows, drills are an essential part of any power tool. But what many don’t realize is there are two different types of drills out there: brushless and brushed.
What’s the difference between the two drills? In this article, our tool specialists and woodworkers will guide you to find the best tool to suit your drilling requirements.
What are Brushes?
In order to understand the difference between a brushless and a brushed drill, it’s first important to understand what brushes are. Brushes are essentially small carbon blocks that make contact with the spinning part of the drill (known as the armature) in order to transfer electrical current.
This electrical current then creates a magnetic field, which interacts with the magnets in the brush or brushless motor. This interaction is what causes the armature to spin, and in turn, causes your drill bit to rotate.
Brushes are a key component of all types of drills, but they’re especially important in brushed drills. That’s because, in a brushless drill, the brushes have been replaced by electronic sensors.
We know that starting with brushes could save you tons of time streamlining your options and work with a tool that delivers the best results.
How Does a Drill Motor Function?
In order to understand how a brushless drill is different from a brushed drill, it’s first important to understand how a drill motor works.
As we mentioned before, brushes are small carbon blocks that make contact with the spinning part of the drill (known as the armature) in order to transfer electrical current. This electrical current then creates a magnetic field, which interacts with the magnets in the drill’s motor.
This interaction is what causes the armature to spin, and in turn, causes the drill bit to rotate.
The key difference between brushless and brushed drills is in how the electrical current is transferred to the armature. In a brushless drill, this transfer is done electronically, while in a brushed drill, it’s done via the brushes.
What is a Brushless Drill?
A brushless dc motor is a type of power drill that uses direct current (DC) instead of alternating current (AC). We find that the biggest advantage of using a brushless technology is that it eliminates the need for brushes, which can wear out over time and cause the drill to lose power.
Additionally, many DIYers add brushless motors as part of their power tools because of their performance and efficiency.
Advantages
1. It’s more energy efficient.
With no brushes rubbing against anything, the brushless unit is more efficient and lasts longer than its counterparts with traditional motor systems. This means you can use your drill for hours on end before having to charge it up again.
We often use brushless drills in several woodworking projects and have done extensively well in delivering quality results.
2. The torque is more constant.
Since there’s no need for brushes to make contact in order to create torque, the power output of all brushless tools is more consistent. We find this results in fewer “stalls” when using the drill and makes it easier to maintain a steady speed.
3. It produces less heat.
Since there’s no friction generated by brushes rubbing against a rotating shaft, brushless motors generate lesser heat. This not only makes them more durable because they can run for longer periods of time without overheating. In addition, this also means that the drill will be cooler to the touch, making it more comfortable to use.
4. It’s easier on your batteries.
The efficiency of a brushless drill motor means that they put less strain on your drill’s batteries, meaning they’ll last longer. Additionally, since the motor doesn’t generate as much heat, the battery will stay cooler, further extending its lifespan.
5. It’s more powerful.
Our team finds that brushless models’ lack of friction makes them more powerful than a brushed motor of the same size. This means that, for a given amount of battery power, a brushless drill will be able to do more work than a brushed drill.
Disadvantages
1. Its parts wear off eventually
The only disadvantage of a brushless motor is that, without brushes to wear down, there’s nothing to “refresh” the motor. This means that, over time, the performance of a brushless motor will slowly degrade as the bearings and other parts start to wear out.
2. It’s more expensive.
While we have a lot of good things to say about this drill type, the initial cost of a brushless motor is higher than a brushed motor. But the increased efficiency and durability come at an extra cost for the initial investment.
3. Not all batteries are compatible.
We find that some batteries (including NiCad [1] and NiMH) are not compatible with most of our brushless motors. This means that you’ll need to invest in a new battery if you want to upgrade to a brushless drill.
4. It’s harder to find replacement parts.
Since the use of brushless drills is relatively new, it could be hard to replace brushes because they are not widely available as brushed motors. When we look for replacement parts, we often outsource outside the state.
This means that it can be difficult to find replacement parts if something goes wrong with your brushless drill. You can avoid delays by purchasing replacement parts in advance.
5. The torque is less constant.
The lack of brushes means that the power output of a brushless motor is more consistent, but we find that the torque is also less constant. This made it difficult for us to use the drill for tasks that require precise control, such as driving screws.
What is a Brushed Drill?
A brushed drill is a type of power drill that relies on carbon brushes to generate the rotating motion necessary to operate the drill bit. These carbon brushes are responsible for transferring electrical current from the motor to the spinning drill bit.
For many, a brushed motor drill is considered to be more durable and long-lasting than its brushless counterpart, as well as being less expensive. However, we find that brushed drills also require more maintenance than brushless drills and may not be as powerful.
Advantages
1. It is a proven technology
Brushed drills’ motors are already standard electronics. These are typically found in toys, small-medium appliances (hairdryers), electric drills and screwdrivers as well as heat guns for soldering stations or other applications where you need high power without size restrictions.
2. It lasts longer
Brushed motors are sturdier and have a higher chance of lasting longer. If you accidentally drop your brushed drill, the chances of it still working are much higher than if you dropped a brushless model.
3. It is cheaper
The technology in brushed motors is cheaper to manufacture. This makes brushed drills less expensive overall.
Disadvantages
1. It requires more maintenance
Brushed drills require more maintenance than brushless drills due to the need to replace the carbon brushes on a regular basis.
2. Brushes are the main source of problems
The carbon brushes in a traditional brushed motor are the main source of problems. Over time, the brushes will wear down and eventually need to be replaced. This can be a difficult and expensive process.
3. It is not as powerful
Compared with brushless drills, we find our brushed dc motor counterparts have a hard time working through tough applications. For the most part, we only used it for small projects that won’t require heavy-duty performance.
Comparing Brushed and Brushless Drills
Performance and Efficiency
Comparing brushed vs brushless drills in terms of power and use is a good start if you’re contemplating of adding this to your power tools.
Permanent magnets are mounted on the armature of a Milwaukee’s brushless motor, with the wire coils surrounding them. This is the opposite of how a brushed motor is configured.
A small circuit board is used to coordinate the current flowing to the windings instead of brushes and a commutator. This allows for much more precise control over the motor’s operation.
We find that our brushless motors are much more efficient than brushed motors and can be found in many cordless power tools, like drills. They tend to be more expensive than brushed motors, but their longer life and higher efficiency make them worth the investment. If you’re looking for a durable and powerful drill, go for brushless motor design options.
Since there are no brushes in a brushless motor, there is far less energy lost due to friction. In fact, brushless motors are about 30% more efficient than brushed motors. This means that a brushless motor will be able to run for a longer period of time on the same battery charge as a brushed motor.
Based on our team’s experience, brushless drills have when it comes to performance output. Since there is no friction created, a brushless motor can produce more power than an equivalent-sized brushed motor.
Lifespan
Our brushless motors also have a longer lifespan than brushed motors. This is due to the fact that there are no brushes in brushless motors, which can wear out over time. In addition, brushless drills typically have fewer moving parts than brushed motors, further increasing their lifespan.
Ease of Use
Brushed models are typically simpler and cheaper to manufacture than Kobalt or Craftsman’s brushless motors. This means that using a brushed motor is usually less expensive than brushless drills. In addition, brushed drills are often easier to use and maintain than brushless drills.
Brushless motors, on the other hand, tend to be more complex and expensive to manufacture. However, this complexity results in a number of advantages for the user. For example, brushless motors are typically more powerful and efficient than brushed motors.
Cordless brushless drills are new drill models of this type that is gaining popularity. It currently makes up 30 to 50 percent of the cordless drill market. For many, it’s all about ease of use while still achieving the performance of a brushless drill but only more mobile.
Although a little more expensive than traditional brushless corded tools, the battery life of these variants is reliable for heavy-duty work.
Maintenance
In terms of maintenance, which is better: brushless vs brushed model? A drill is a tool you need to take care of any construction handiwork at home, in the office or woodcraft. And it’s best to go for tools that generate power for tough tasks.
We find that our brushed motors require periodic maintenance and regular replacement brushes when used more frequently. Brushless dc motors, on the other hand, require less maintenance and still get any drill motor work done efficiently.
Moreover, brushless units lack brushes that require almost no maintenance to keep them running. Its power efficiency is one of the several advantages why beginner DIYers invest in this type of power tool.
Price
Brushed motors are typically less expensive than brushless motors. This is due to the fact that brushed motors are simpler and cheaper to manufacture than brushless motors. However, the increased efficiency and lifespan of brushless motors may make them a better value in the long run.
Which is Better, Brushless or Brushed Drills?
There is no clear answer as to whether a brushless or brushed motor is better. We know that each type of drill has its own advantages and disadvantages.
In general, brushless motors are more powerful and efficient than brushed motors. However, brushed motors are typically less expensive and easier to use and maintain.
Ultimately, the best type of drill for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences.
Which Should You Purchase?
If you are looking for a powerful and efficient drill without manually use an awl tool, then we recommend a brushless drill as the best option. However, if you are looking for a less expensive and easier-to-use drill, then a brushed drill is the better choice.
In purchasing an appropriate drill, it’s important to identify first your requirements. You need to determine the specific job or projects that you will use it for. In this way, you can easily narrow down your choices and find the best one that will suit your needs.
FAQ
Is a brushless motor worth the extra money?
A brushless motor is worth the extra money if you’re looking at its long-term value. Though typically more expensive than brushed motors, you are assured that you’re getting quality results for your projects. In addition, we believe that brushless motors are more powerful and efficient with a longer lifespan.
How do I know if a drill is brushless?
The drill is brushless if it uses magnets to power it. The brushes in a regular drill will wear out quickly, and eventually, need to be replaced. A brushless motor will not have this issue, as there are no brushes to wear out.
How can you tell if a motor is brushless?
The motor is brushless if the drill contains three wires. These are seen in the armature, which is the rotating part of the motor. If there are two wires, then the drill is a brushed motor.
Conclusion
Our tool specialists and woodworkers highly recommend that you take the time to look think through the kind of projects you will be working on before purchasing this tool.
If you’re looking for a durable and powerful drill, then a brushless motor is worth the extra money. With no brushes to wear out, and more power and efficiency, you’ll be glad you made the investment.
- Black+Decker MM2000 Review — Is This Lawn Mower Worth it? (2023) - September 29, 2023
- Dewalt DWE575SB Review (2023) — Is it Worth it? - September 24, 2023
- DeWalt DCS369B Review (2023) — Cutting Edge Precision and More - September 23, 2023
